Could Argos have dominated fashion in the UK?

Could Argos have dominated fashion in the UK?

It has the infrastructure, tools and high-street presence to pull off any new venture – and with its decision to sell the Tu clothing range, Argos had the opportunity to really shake up the fashion market.

Sainsbury’s really stepped into the limelight during early 2018. Hot on the heels of the Tesco-Booker deal, its merger with Asda looked to create a partnership with a slice of the market greater than Tesco – Sainsbury’s and Asda shared 31.4% as of April 2018, compared to the 27.6% claimed by their big blue rival.

Although the move was somewhat overshadowed by Sainsbury’s chief executive Mike Coupe singing the wrong words to We’re in the Money ahead of an interview with ITV, it adds to a growing unease among competitors that Sainsbury’s could dominate the market in more ways than one – especially given the major inroads it’s making with a high-street favourite.

No laughing matter

Back on April Fool’s Day in 2016, the day’s main business story was far from a joke.

Sainsbury’s was given the all-clear to buy Argos in a deal worth £1.4 billion, signalling the end of Home Retail Group and the beginning of a “multi-product, multi-channel” era for this all-new partnership. Competitors sat up, listened and most likely grimaced: after all, this was the UK’s second-largest supermarket joining forces with a company known for its market-leading delivery service.

When the landmark purchase was finally completed five months later on September 2nd, chief executive of Sainsbury’s Argos, John Rogers, reiterated the business’ digital-first push by saying that “[t]he way people shop is changing – customers expect choice, convenience, flexibility, fast delivery and to shop whenever and wherever they want”.

Of course, by looking at Argos’ model, it was a match made in heaven for shoppers:

  • Customers are able to return products free of charge for 30 days after purchase;
  • Delivery options from as little as four hours, alongside next-day and named-day; and
  • The chance to click and collect from Argos stores.

Fast-forward to March 2018, and Sainsbury’s finally confirmed that the Tu clothing line would be sold at Argos effective April 25th, with the potential to make huge waves in the fashion market – and forcing competitors to consider their own ability to match the rapidly evolving demand for quick delivery.

The team at SHIFT and I are huge fans of what Argos has to offer consumers. However, this move into clothing retail felt like a huge missed opportunity to grab the market by the throat.

Delivery options that don’t truly deliver

Immediately, the weirdest decision Sainsbury’s made was to exclude this new clothing range from its much-loved same-day home delivery. This could have been a truly market-changing offering. Instead, it simply offered its standard, next, and named-day delivery services – alongside click and collect from new Argos locations. Sainsbury’s was, in effect, expanding its range to Argos locations. It was hardly groundbreaking, especially given many new Argos shops are just store-in-store offerings inside Sainsbury’s.

Argos delivery truck

The shift only confuses loyal Argos customers. Rapid delivery is something we’ve all come to expect from Argos over the last few years – it still proudly, and rightly, makes a lot of noise about the many people it’s bailed out of a bad situation with last-minute, same-day delivery.

By stepping back from this core KSP – and one that has become emblematic of the brand – it left the door wide open for the competition, as Argos simply joined the ranks of many retailers who all offer next-day delivery on fashion products. Why would people limit themselves to a necessary trip to Argos to get a same-day click and collect order when a trip to any of its store locations would also showcase countless nearby stores, and ones where you can try the clothes on before buying them?

What’s more, most of Sainsbury’s competitors offered more than just one brand to sell.

It takes more than Tu to tango

While Tu has very much established itself as Sainsbury’s answer to George or F&F – a credible, good-value and decent-quality supermarket clothing range – why, with 18 months to plan, did Argos not consider adding other clothing brands to its own range to reflect its business model in other product lines?

Admittedly, Sainsbury’s sells products from Russell Athletic and Admiral, and it makes sense to push its own products from launch. However, Argos is known for its incredibly diverse and well-rounded product selection – it has the door-stopping catalogue to prove it – and even a small commitment to two or three brands from launch, or an announcement that more may be on the way, would have sent more positive signals to customers, as well as the promise of more variance in style and cost.

Instead, this tentative step into clothing retail leaves consumers feeling underwhelmed. While the Tu line-up is worth £1 billion annually to Sainsbury’s, consumers rarely – if ever – build their wardrobe from one source alone. Is Sainsbury’s missing a trick, and losing revenue potential, by only selling Tu products?

Inside Argos' new-look stores

Competitors are already innovating

Sainsbury’s failure to capitalise on a unique same-day delivery possibility is also undermined by other market leaders that look at ways to make their own brand stand out from the crowd. Online, one of the most head-turning of these is Asos’ “try now, pay later” model offered through its partnership with the Klarna platform.

The reason for this relationship is simple: Asos knows exactly who its customers are. As Essential Retail reported in 2017, its frequency of returns is so unpredictable that even data scientists can’t build a business model to predict its fortunes. But it knows that its popularity is down to this flexibility, so it has introduced the Klarna payment method, which only charges for the goods that are kept and not returned.

Meanwhile, bricks and mortar high-street fashion retailers are being ever-more daring. Zara’s “radical new store concept” at Westfield Stratford is a perfect example of this, combining shopper demands with their growing taste for technological wizardry. For starters, Zara’s new self-checkout area can automatically identify products, meaning shoppers only have to confirm what’s in their basket before paying for them.

However, it boasts a dedicated, automated click-and-collect area serviced by a pair of small warehouses. Using a simple QR or PIN code, customers who place orders online can have their order delivered to a secure mailbox while “[b]ehind the scenes, a robot moves through the warehouses, delivering packages to mailboxes”.

While Argos famously has a more human approach to order collection and distribution, it’s fundamentally unable to showcase its range like Zara can. Innovating with, say, interactive screens to “build” a look before buying the clothes could be a good way to combine technology and brand experience, while also twisting the arms of captive shoppers to buy more products in-store.

Consumer in Argos ordering products

Triple trouble

While we hold out hope that these issues are a product of anticipated teething problems, as it stands, Sainsbury’s cautious start with Argos doesn't live up to its full potential for three key reasons:

  1. It doesn’t offer its exclusive, market-leading same-day home delivery on clothing, therefore confusing its loyal customers used to its flexibility;
  2. There’s a sole focus on Tu, with no immediate intention to give Argos’ fans another diverse range of products they’ve come to expect and rely on; and
  3. Long-standing competitors are already innovating, and they’ll always look to beat – or at the very least match – their rivals.

Argos could have made serious waves. Whether it realises it or not, it’s sitting on a multi-channel format that could be a market leader for years to come, but it hasn’t fully committed to this, so it needs to move quickly to avoid competitors beating them at their own game.

After 18 months of planning, Argos didn't fully take note of the major reasons people like us love the company. It needs to truly analyse its customers – as Asos and Zara have – and play to its unique strengths. Should Argos have kept its powder dry before moving into clothing with an industry-dominating, multi-brand proposition? Only time will tell.

Recent Articles

The art of the possible: Puma's push for personalisation at New York flagship

With its relative underdog status in the market, Puma is going beyond simply bringing a big presence with its NYC flagship store, using every trick in the book to win new brand advocates through carefully curated, brand-related experiences.

Augmented reality: Finally enriching the customer experience with more than simple gimmicks

With the right ecommerce platform, businesses have a real opportunity to enhance the customer journey with the clever adoption of augmented reality – and now’s the time to test it out.

Could Amazon make packageless returns the new norm?

Amazon's initiative to remove packaging from its returns process may be the perfect way to cut costs, but it's also a great way to respond to consumer demand for less waste – and make one big-box retailer in particular more popular at an incredibly critical time. Will packageless returns become a new retail norm?

The art of the possible: Puma's push for personalisation at New York flagship

With its relative underdog status in the market, Puma is going beyond simply bringing a big presence with its NYC flagship store, using every trick in the book to win new brand advocates through carefully curated, brand-related experiences.

Augmented reality: Finally enriching the customer experience with more than simple gimmicks

With the right ecommerce platform, businesses have a real opportunity to enhance the customer journey with the clever adoption of augmented reality – and now’s the time to test it out.

Could Amazon make packageless returns the new norm?

Amazon's initiative to remove packaging from its returns process may be the perfect way to cut costs, but it's also a great way to respond to consumer demand for less waste – and make one big-box retailer in particular more popular at an incredibly critical time. Will packageless returns become a new retail norm?

In-store optimisation: Treating physical stores as real-life websites

Retailers need to treat stores like websites. Just as developers use technology to evolve the quality of a company's online offering, businesses can use the same approach to gather insights on the high street and deliver a best-in-class brand experience.

M&S Little Shop: Pint-sized prizes that convert on a huge scale

While it’s had its fair share of negative headlines, the Little Shop offered by Marks & Spencer has a keen focus on the bottom line, basic human psychology and the brand itself – and delivers countless benefits at a crucial time.

High street banking is dying. What can retailers learn from Santander’s clever Work Café?

Banks are withdrawing from the high street at a drastic rate, driven by ever-lower demand for in-branch services. Will Santander's Work Café make physical banking relevant to a new, technologically empowered generation?

Greggs’ “adapt or die” mantra is the blueprint all businesses must follow

Greggs’ decision to reconsider its high-street presence in favour of motorway services, drive-throughs and industrial parks has helped it top £1 billion in sales for the first time. It’s time for every retailer to learn from the company’s success and seriously consider their physical strategy.

The SHIFT On-Site Search Score: How retailers are hiding their products from customers

Combining a survey of 1,500 British customers with a bespoke test which ranks 40 British retailers across a variety of metrics, the SHIFT On-Site Search Score assesses the difference between consumer expectations of retailers’ on-site search and the reality of their capabilities.

The 2019 State of Retail Report

Building on the foundations of our 2018 State of Omnichannel Report, we spoke to 10,000 consumers to understand the demands of the modern British customer.

Fukubukuro: The lucky dip where everyone’s a winner

Sales events like Black Friday are regularly lambasted as wasteful and pointless. Is Fukubukuro the craze that can fulfil retailers’ needs and silence their critics in one fell swoop?

Are high-street retailers doing enough to win new online customers?

Omnichannel retailers must beat, and not just compete, with ecommerce pure-plays by prioritising new customer relationships online.

The 2019 Retail Experience Score (RES) 100

In our first-ever RES 100, we measure 100 of the high street’s most established omnichannel retailers across six core areas.

How can you offer an in-store experience if you can’t deliver the basics?

In recent months, there’s been much talk of retailers needing to offer an experience on the high street – but is this really at the top of the British consumer’s shopping list?

If there’s one thing high-street retailers must invest in during 2019, it’s this

To make the biggest impact across all channels in 2019, high-street retailers must drive towards accurate inventory, as both customers and the businesses themselves will stand to gain incredible benefits from it.

Free and fast click and collect: The next industry standard

Fast and free click and collect isn’t just nice to have – it’s a necessity if you want to remain competitive and keep people coming to your store.

Five years on, Black Friday still thrives in the UK – whether retailers like it or not

Black Friday is always forecast to be bigger and better than ever, and in the face of heightened online spending, high-street retailers must embrace omnichannel if they are to keep up with internet-only rivals.

The very real problem facing British retailers that nobody is talking about

Everyone hates slow websites, but retailers should hate them more than anyone else - after all, billions of pounds in revenue is being lost to poor web performance.

Amazon Fashion’s Pop Up Shop Live sets out to influence the influencers

Amazon’s UK fashion presence is far from consolidated. Was Amazon Fashion’s Pop Up Shop Live – its first European foray into physical retail – a successful step in bridging this gap? SHIFT Magazine visited the store on its opening day to find out.

Zara Westfield: Pushing the boundaries, or putting up barriers?

Technology is being increasingly used in wonderful ways by retail giants, yet despite Zara’s admirable efforts to raise the bar, we found there to be a difference between promise and execution.

The art of the possible: Decathlon

SHIFT Magazine visited Decathlon’s flagship store in Surrey Quays, London to see how its highly publicised refurbishment aims to satisfy the demands of the modern, omnichannel consumer.